Empowering Netanyahu: A Perilous Path for American Interests

In the theater of global politics, few actors have consistently placed American interests in jeopardy quite like Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The ongoing support from American politicians, spanning multiple administrations, has emboldened Netanyahu to pursue policies that often run counter to U.S. national security interests. This reality has been starkly highlighted by the recent assassinations of Hezbollah and Hamas leaders, events that have only further destabilized an already volatile region.

A Historical Pattern of Risk

The Clinton Administration: Netanyahu's first tenure as Prime Minister in the late 1990s was marked by friction with the Clinton administration, which was heavily invested in the Oslo Accords. Netanyahu's expansion of settlements in the West Bank directly undermined the peace process, infuriating Palestinian leaders and complicating U.S. diplomatic efforts. This move not only stalled peace talks but also fueled anti-American sentiment in the Arab world, setting the stage for future conflicts.

The Bush Administration: During the George W. Bush era, Netanyahu, then serving as Finance Minister, vocally supported the U.S. invasion of Iraq. His assertions that toppling Saddam Hussein would benefit Israel and stabilize the Middle East proved disastrously misguided. The subsequent chaos in Iraq strengthened Iran’s influence and gave rise to extremist groups, directly impacting U.S. and allied forces in the region.

The Obama Administration: Netanyahu's relationship with President Obama was notoriously contentious. His 2015 speech to the U.S. Congress, bypassing the White House to denounce the Iran nuclear deal, was a blatant attempt to undermine U.S. foreign policy. This unprecedented move not only strained U.S.-Israel relations but also complicated diplomatic efforts to curb Iran's nuclear ambitions.

The Trump Administration: With President Trump, Netanyahu found a kindred spirit. The decision to move the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem and the subsequent recognition of Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights were celebrated by Netanyahu but condemned by many international actors. These moves ignited protests, incited violence, and further isolated the U.S. from key allies in Europe and the Middle East.

Recent Assassinations and Their Ramifications

The recent targeted killings of senior Hezbollah and Hamas leaders, reportedly supported by Netanyahu, exemplify the ongoing peril. These assassinations, while lauded by some as necessary for Israeli security, have provoked retaliatory attacks and increased tensions across the region. Such actions complicate U.S. efforts to broker peace and undermine the stability essential for American strategic interests.

Other Noteworthy Blunders

The Gaza Wars: Netanyahu’s handling of conflicts in Gaza has repeatedly drawn criticism. The 2014 Gaza war, with its high civilian casualties and destruction, attracted international condemnation and fueled anti-Israel sentiment globally. Each military escalation has not only deepened the humanitarian crisis but also diminished prospects for a two-state solution, a long-standing U.S. policy goal.

Settlement Expansion: Netanyahu's persistent expansion of Israeli settlements in the West Bank has been a significant stumbling block in peace negotiations. These settlements, considered illegal under international law, have been a source of constant tension, provoking Palestinian anger and leading to periodic violence. This policy directly contradicts U.S. calls for a halt to settlement activity, complicating America's role as a mediator.

The Iran Nuclear Deal: Netanyahu’s relentless campaign against the Iran nuclear deal, both during its negotiation and after its implementation, has further strained U.S.-Israel relations. His push for aggressive measures against Iran has often been at odds with broader U.S. strategic interests, which favor diplomatic solutions to prevent nuclear proliferation.

Impact on the U.S. Presidential Race

Netanyahu’s actions are also adding fuel to the fire of the U.S. presidential race. As candidates grapple with Middle Eastern policy, Netanyahu's provocations serve as a litmus test for their diplomatic savvy and their ability to handle complex international issues. His actions provide ammunition for those who argue that Trump's foreign policy has been reckless and detrimental to U.S. interests.

Stoking Antisemitic Attitudes

Moreover, Netanyahu’s actions are being exploited by actors who wish to see the downfall of the West. Far-right groups and other malicious actors are using his policies to stoke antisemitic attitudes, particularly among younger voters and the far right in the U.S. This dangerous trend threatens to undermine social cohesion and fuel division within American society. By empowering Netanyahu without scrutiny, American politicians inadvertently feed into these narratives, creating a breeding ground for hate and extremism.

The Way Forward

American politicians must recognize that empowering Netanyahu without question poses significant risks to U.S. national security interests. His policies often provoke regional instability and complicate U.S. diplomatic efforts. While the U.S.-Israel alliance remains vital, it is crucial for American leaders to critically evaluate Netanyahu's actions and their implications.

Netanyahu's tenure is marked by a series of decisions that have consistently placed American interests at risk. From undermining peace processes to provoking conflicts and bypassing diplomatic norms, his actions have often run counter to U.S. goals. As the U.S. navigates its foreign policy in the Middle East, it must do so with a clear-eyed understanding of the perils posed by an emboldened Netanyahu. Continuing to empower him without scrutiny is a path fraught with danger, one that American politicians must tread with caution.